Don't Build a Grace Period Into Your Late Pickup Fee
Start the late fee at closing. If you want to let someone off, do it at the counter.
Say the doors lock at six. At 6:20 a car pulls in for the two dogs still in the back, and someone on your team has stayed twenty minutes past close to hand them back.
What a built-in hour does to closing time
Your sign says six and a grace period in the rule says seven, so the front desk ends up explaining which one counts. Waive the fee yourself and six stays the only closing time. The waiver stays a favor, and you notice when it's the same car again.
Automatic grace has a point: it's consistent, and nobody has to charge a good customer for ten minutes. But it's consistent about the hour it gives away, and someone still has to say no to the car that pulls in an hour and ten minutes late.
Late counts in whole hours
A late pickup surcharge being set up on a boarding service in a demo organization. Not a real facility.
The surcharge can't forgive the first ten minutes, because Cutoff Hours takes a whole number. At 0, 6:01 is late and 6:00 isn't. At 1, the car at 6:20 pays nothing, and neither does the one at 6:59. It also needs your hours set for that day, and with none, nothing is ever late. Leave Store Opening Safety Period at 0 here. It exists for pickups just after you open, and a large number would swallow a 6:20 pickup too.
Check the Fees tab before you turn this on. If you've also set up the flat Late Pickup Fee there, a boarding stay that leaves at noon or later can be charged both.
Taking the fee off for one owner
The surcharge lands once per stay, on the last night you bill for, as its own line for each dog when Break out as separate line item is ticked. Two dogs on one stay get two lines.
The invoice for a three-night stay, picked up at 6:20 PM with closing at 6:00 PM. A demo organization.
To waive it, open the invoice's Edit page, use Remove Invoice Line (the trash icon) on each dog's surcharge, and Save. That works only while the invoice is Pending; once it's posted, Modify Invoice voids it and makes a new Pending copy. Undo Check-Out and a second check-out both rebuild the invoice from your rules, so a removed line comes back if the pickup still counts as late. Remove it last.
At the door it sounds like this:
It's twenty past six, so there's a fee tonight. I took it off this time. Next time it stays on.
Tell owners the closing time and the fee when they reserve. Decide ahead of time who may waive it, so the person at the door at 6:20 isn't making it up.